An Old Fashioned is the hardest cocktail to translate to zero-proof. There is nowhere for the drink to hide. No citrus, no fizz, no froth, no fruit. The whisky has to be replaced by something that brings warmth, oak, and weight. Here is the working approach.

What an Old Fashioned actually is

Five components in a real Old Fashioned: whisky, sugar, water (from dilution), aromatic bitters, expressed citrus peel oil. The proportions are 60ml whisky, 5ml sugar syrup, 2 dashes Angostura, 25ml dilution from stirring with ice, peel garnish.

The drink works because of four things: alcohol warmth, oak depth, aromatic-bitter spice, and the slow temperature shift from large ice. A zero-proof version has to replicate the latter three and find a substitute for the first.

The five things to replicate

1. Warmth. Alcohol's evaporation off the tongue is what makes a spirit feel warm. Without alcohol, the warmth has to come from spice (clove, cinnamon, allspice) or chilli-tincture in trace amounts.

2. Oak / vanilla / caramel. The whisky's barrel-aged character. Substitute: a strong cold-steeped chicory and roasted-barley tea, or a commercial NA whisky.

3. Aromatic bitters. Critical. Use real Angostura (2 dashes per drink contains negligible alcohol). The bitter spice is what sells the drink as adult.

4. Sweetness. A small amount. Use gula melaka or maple syrup instead of plain sugar for more depth.

5. Slow dilution. Large ice cube. Stir long. The water content is what turns the drink from intense to drinkable.

NA whiskies worth buying in KL

Lyre's American Malt: the most-recognisable NA whisky. Vanilla, oak, mild caramel. RM 130-160 a 700ml bottle. Available at Village Grocer, Mercato, BIG Pharmacy.

Ritual Zero Proof Whiskey Alternative: sharper, more rye-like. Imported, RM 180-220.

Seedlip Spice 94: not a whisky substitute per se, but the allspice-cardamom-oak profile works in this context. RM 200-260.

For value: make your own concentrate. Cold-steep 30g of roasted barley + 2g chicory + 2g charred oak chips (toasted in a dry pan) in 500ml water overnight. Strain. Adjust with a touch of maple syrup. Approximates the body and oak character at RM 4 per litre.

The working recipe

  • NA whisky (Lyre's, Ritual, or homemade concentrate) 50ml
  • Gula melaka syrup 5ml (or maple syrup)
  • Angostura aromatic bitters, 2 dashes
  • Cherry juice or strong cold-brewed black tea 5ml (for body)
  • Large ice cube
  • Orange peel to garnish

Method: stir all liquids over ice in a mixing glass for 30 seconds (longer than a real Old Fashioned, to compensate for less alcohol-driven volatility). Strain over a large cube in a rocks glass. Express the orange peel and drop in.

The bitters question

Two dashes of Angostura aromatic bitters contain about 0.06ml of alcohol, less than what a banana ferments naturally. If you are zero-proof for taste preference, the bitters are fine. If you are zero-proof for religious or medical reasons (e.g. pregnancy, recovery), use NA bitters such as Free Spirit or All The Bitter.

What it should taste like

Round, slightly sweet, warming through the spice, with a long oak-vanilla finish. Drinks at a similar pace to a real Old Fashioned. The single biggest difference: less linger of alcohol-warmth on the palate, more emphasis on spice and oak character.

Related reading

Frequently asked questions

How do I build a non-alcoholic Old Fashioned?

Use 50ml of NA whisky (Lyre's, Ritual, or a homemade barley-chicory-oak concentrate), 5ml gula melaka or maple syrup, 2 dashes Angostura, and 5ml cherry juice or cold-brewed black tea for body. Stir over ice for 30 seconds, strain over a large cube, express orange peel and drop in.

What does the NA Old Fashioned need to replicate?

Five things. Warmth from spice. Oak and vanilla from chicory and roasted-barley tea or NA whisky. Aromatic bitters (real Angostura) for the bitter-spice that sells the drink as adult. Sweetness from gula melaka. Slow dilution from a large ice cube.

Which NA whisky should I buy in KL?

Lyre's American Malt is the most recognisable at RM 130 to 160, vanilla and oak, at Village Grocer and Mercato. Ritual Zero Proof is sharper and more rye-like at RM 180 to 220. Seedlip Spice 94 at RM 200 to 260 is not a whisky substitute but works.

Are NA Old Fashioneds halal-friendly given the bitters?

Two dashes of Angostura contain about 0.06ml of alcohol, less than what a banana ferments naturally. If you are zero-proof for taste preference, the bitters are fine. If you are zero-proof for religious reasons or pregnancy or recovery, use NA bitters such as Free Spirit or All The Bitter.

Where can I order an NA Old Fashioned in PJ?

Both bars build this on request with the gula melaka twist. Dissolved Solids at 43-1 Jalan SS20/11 Damansara Kim; WhatsApp +60 11-4008 7607. Soluble Solids at 50-1 Jalan SS2/24; WhatsApp +60 11-1682 8651. Tell the bartender if you want NA bitters for fully alcohol-free.